Page 40 - Bullion World Issue 10 Volume 05 October 2025
P. 40

2025
            ullion
           Bullion World | Volume 5 | Issue 10 | October 2025  IGC 2025: Where The World Meets India, Day 3 Highlights
           B
                 W
                   orld |
                                              ober
                                  ssue 10 | O
                        V
                         olume 5 | I
                                            ct
                    Debate 3: One India, One Price for Gold



























             Mr Dileep Narayanan, Head Bullion & Treasury, Malabar Group, Mr Avinash Gupta, Vice-Chairman, GJC,
              Mr Shivanshu Mehta, VP - Bullion, MCX, Mr Surendra Mehta, National Secretary, IBJA, Mr Gagan Bhai,
                                        Executive Director, MMTC-PAMP India Pvt. Ltd


                                Moderator: Mr Shivanshu Mehta, VP – Bullion, MCX

           Proponents (Mr Dileep Narayanan & Mr Avinash Gupta)   Opponents (Mr Surendra Mehta, Mr Gagan Bhai)


            •   Implementing a unified gold price increases        •   India’s diverse regional demand, logistics,
                transparency, fairness, and consumer trust             and cost structures make a single, uniform
                nationwide.                                            price impractical.
            •   Malabar Group’s example demonstrates               •   Variations can range from 0.25% to 1%
                how a consistent benchmark simplifies    VS            across regions, influenced by local factors.
                pricing and boosts consumer confidence.            •   IBJA’s daily declared price functions as a
            •   Clear separation of raw gold costs from                benchmark but isn’t meant as a fixed selling
                design/making charges improves honesty                 price; flexibility is vital to manage costs and
                and transparency in pricing.                           operational realities.



         Implementation & Challenges:
         •   Reconciling retail and wholesale prices, managing regional inventory, and integrating existing reference
             prices from MCX, IBJA, and LBMA are complex.
         •   Technology-driven platforms like India’s emerging Electronic Gold Receipt (EGR) system could facilitate
             better price transparency.


         Consumer Trust & Industry Outlook:
         •   63% of the audience Favour a “One India, One Price” approach for greater transparency.
         •   Achieving full uniformity remains aspirational; incremental efforts and technological solutions will help bridge
             regional disparities.


         Summary:
         •   The goal is to foster a more transparent, trusted, and efficient gold market through harmonized benchmarks
             and technology, balancing market heterogeneity.


            40
   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43   44   45